5 Best Pacifiers for Newborn Babies

Picking a pacifier for your baby can be tricky. If your child isn’t comfortable with the pacifier, they will not accept it. You also need something which is durable, and does not pose a danger to your child. To help you out with this task we’ve reviewed some of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies.

Which pacifier is the best for breastfed baby?

First of all, you need to choose a pacifier which is the right size for your baby. This is important because it reduces the risk of choking. To avoid this, it’s best to get a pacifier which is made from a single piece. Also look at the age recommendation on the packaging. This helps you choose the right size.

You’ll also want a soft nipple that fits well in your baby’s mouth. Many pacifiers have nipples which flatten in the mouth. This mimics what the nipple naturally does when your baby feeds. Also pay attention to the design. Look for a rounded tip. This makes it easier for your baby to latch onto the pacifier.

You may also want to use an orthodontic pacifier. These are specifically designed to help your baby’s palate and jaw develop.

The material used in the pacifier is also important. Ideally, you’ll want something made from silicone or latex. Latex pacifiers are softer, but wear out faster. You also get pacifiers made from natural rubber, which are usually a bit more expensive.

The 5 Top Pacifier for Breastfeeding Babies

1. Tommee Tippee Ultra-light Silicone Pacifier

Check price on Amazon

Pros:

Ultra-light, so your baby can easily hold it

Symmetrical design makes it easier to insert

Made from food grade silicone

Cons:

Does occasionally fall out

Pacifier tears easily

Nipple might be too big for smaller babies

The biggest problem with pacifiers is that they often fall out. And this is what we really liked about this product. It’s ultra-light weight, meaning your baby can easily hold it. This also means you won’t have to constantly put it back in your baby’s mouth.

The pacifier also features a symmetrical design, meaning there is no right or wrong way up. This saves you from figuring out if you’re putting it in the correct way. After all, you already have enough to do and this is one less thing to worry about. This pacifier is also made from food grade silicone which is a must for your babies safety.

2. Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers

Check price on Amazon

Pros:

Comfortable, ergonomic design

Design makes it easier to breathe

Made from a single piece

Cons:

Nipple is quite narrow

Sometimes leaves marks on your baby’s mouth

This pacifier is quite heavy

Some media outlets have rated this as the best pacifier for 2023. In our opinion this is absolutely true. What’s great about this pacifier is that it features an ergonomic design. This design allows it to fit easily and curve around your babies nose and chin.

It even has a special cut out for your babies nose. This allows your child to breathe easily while holding the pacifier in its mouth. Something else we liked is that this product is made from a single piece.

This means there are no joins or edges which could potentially cut or hurt your baby. This is actually a guideline recommended by the American Academy of Pediatrics. In addition to this, it’s probably the softest pacifier which we’ve reviewed so far. In fact, it’s actually recommended for premature babies.

3. Phillips AVENT Soothie Pacifier

Check price on Amazon

Pros:

Orthodontic design

Made from medical grade silicone

Extremely durable

Cons:

The nipple is quite hard, which might be a problem

Doesn’t have air vents, or a cut out for your babies nose

Doesn’t feature an ergonomic design like other pacifiers.

This pacifier is manufactured by Phillips, one of the world’s leading suppliers of health care technology. Not only that, it’s actually used in hospitals around the world. Both of these facts are a good indication that it’s a high quality product.

Some of the key features include the following. First of all, it’s made from a single piece, which is important for your baby’s safety. It also features an orthodontic design. One issue with pacifiers is that they can affect development. With this design, the risk of that is minimized.

In fact, this is one of the best pacifiers for parents concerned about their child’s teeth and gums. Along with this, the pacifier is made from medical grade silicone. This means it’s 100% safe for your baby and contains no harmful chemicals.

It also means the pacifier is durable and will last a long time. Actually, this is probably the most durable pacifier on our list. It’s more than strong enough to use while your baby is teething. And while it’s smaller than most other pacifiers, it’s not small enough to pose a choking hazard.

4. Tomee Tippee Breast-like Pacifier

Check price on Amazon

Pros:

Design mimics the look and feel of a nipple

Doesn’t have a shield, easier for baby to breathe

No shield prevents moisture build up

Cons:

Nipple might be too hard for some babies

This pacifier is quite heavy compared to others

The design makes them hard to clean

If you’re transitioning from breast to bottle, then this pacifier is fantastic. Out of all the products we’ve reviewed this has by far the best design. It’s meant to exactly mimic the look and feel of a mothers nipple. It also has a skin-like texture which can bend and extend just like a natural nipple.

This makes it the best pacifier for newborn breastfed baby. The pacifier is also great for parents who are worried that a pacifier may interfere with their child’s growth. For example, unlike other pacifiers it doesn’t feature a shield. This makes it kinder and gentler on your babies skin.

The base of this pacifier also curves away from your babies face, and this helps enhance comfort. The design also improves ventilation and makes breathing easier. As well as that, it prevents moisture build up, which can irritate your baby. All in all, this is probably the best pacifier for breastfed baby who won’t take one.

5. MAM Original Matte Baby Pacifier

Check price on Amazon

Pros:

Extra-soft nipple

Shield has air holes

Comes with sterilizing storage case

Cons:

The sterilization box doesn’t always work

You cannot attach a pacifier clip

Water can get trapped in the nipple

This pacifier for breastfeeding babyhas by far the best nipple we’ve seen. It’s incredibly soft and comfortable. This makes it perfect for parents who are concerned about their babies jaw and teeth. It’s also a good choice for premature babies or babies who have difficulty with harder nipples. For example, this pacifier has an extremely soft texture which feels just like a real nipple.

The shield also has air holes. These air holes also make it gentler on your babies skin, and also make breathing easier. This isn’t something we’ve seen on any other pacifier, which places this one ahead of the crowd.

In addition to this, it also features a symmetrical nipple. Another nice thing is that this product comes with a sterilizing storage case. This is extremely useful. You simply place a few drops of water into this case and pop it into the microwave for about a minute.

Sandra McNeil, PhD.

Sandra has over 13 years of experience as a child psychologist, both as a practitioner and researcher. She has a Bachelor's in child psychology from the University of Michigan-Ann Arbor and then she did her master's in Psychology in Education (focused on Children & Families) at Columbia University, NY. She has been writing for health and child-related publications for over 5 years now.